Understanding the difference between credit union and bank

Understanding the differences between a credit union and a bank is essential for making informed decisions about where to manage your finances. While both institutions offer financial services such as savings, loans, and investment accounts, they operate under distinct principles and structures.

Credit unions are member-owned cooperatives that prioritize serving their community and typically offer competitive rates and personalized service. Banks are for-profit entities owned by shareholders, aiming to maximize profits.

This blog explores the differences in operations, services, benefits, and considerations between credit unions vs. banks, empowering readers to choose the financial institution that best aligns with their needs and values.

What is a credit union?

A credit union is a financial cooperative owned and controlled by its members, who are typically individuals sharing a common bond, such as living in the same community or belonging to the same organization.

Unlike traditional banks, which are for-profit entities owned by shareholders, credit unions operate on a not-for-profit basis. This structure allows them to prioritize member service and community impact over maximizing shareholder returns.

Characteristics of credit unions

Credit unions possess several characteristics distinguishing them from traditional banks and financial institutions. Understanding these characteristics helps illustrate the unique benefits and principles upon which credit unions operate.

Ownership of members

Credit unions are owned and governed by their members, who typically share a common bond, such as living in the same community, belonging to the same organization, or working for the same employer. Credit union members have equal ownership rights and can participate in the credit union's decision-making processes, such as voting for the board of directors.

Non-profit structure

Unlike banks that operate for-profit and are accountable to shareholders, credit unions operate as not-for-profit financial cooperatives. This structure allows them to prioritize member interests by offering competitive rates on savings and loans, and lower fees. Profits generated are often reinvested into the credit union or returned to members as dividends or improved services.

Member focus

The primary mission of credit unions is to serve their members' financial needs effectively and responsibly. This member-centric focus drives decisions about product offerings, personalized customer service, and community involvement. Credit unions strive to build long-term relationships with their members based on trust, transparency, and mutual benefit.

Democratic governance

Credit unions operate under a democratic governance model, where members have a say in the institution's operations and policies. Members elect a volunteer board of directors from among their peers to oversee the credit union's strategic direction and ensure it remains aligned with member interests.

Community orientation

Many credit unions commit to supporting local communities. They may sponsor community events, offer financial education programs, and support local charities and initiatives. This community orientation reflects credit unions' role as integral parts of the communities they serve.

Focus on financial inclusion

Credit unions often prioritize financial inclusion by providing access to financial services for underserved or marginalized communities. They may offer products and services tailored to the unique needs of diverse member groups, promoting economic empowerment and stability.

Regulation and deposit insurance

Credit unions are regulated financial institutions subject to oversight by provincial or territorial regulatory authorities in Canada. Deposits held in credit unions are typically insured up to a limit by provincial deposit insurance programs or the federal Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation (CDIC), protecting members' savings.

Cooperative principal

Credit unions adhere to cooperative principles, including voluntary and open membership, democratic member control, member economic participation, autonomy and independence, education, training, and concern for the community. These principles guide credit unions in their operations and interactions with members and the community.

What is a bank?

A bank is a financial institution that provides various financial services to individuals, businesses, and governments. Banks play a crucial role in the economy by facilitating financial transactions, offering savings and checking accounts, providing loans and mortgages, and offering investment products.

Key characteristics of banks

Banks, like the top 5 banks in Canada, are essential financial institutions offering services to individuals, businesses, and governments. Here are the key characteristics that distinguish banks from other entities.

Acceptance of deposits

Banks accept customer deposits held in various accounts, such as savings accounts, checking accounts, and certificates of deposit (CDs). Depositors entrust their funds to banks for safekeeping and access.

Lending and credit services

A primary function of banks is to provide loans and credit to borrowers. Banks evaluate the creditworthiness of borrowers based on factors such as income, credit history, and collateral. Types of bank loans include personal loans, mortgages, business loans, and lines of credit.

Financial intermediation

Banks act as intermediaries between depositors and borrowers, facilitating the flow of funds in the economy. They channel savings from depositors into loans and investments that support economic growth and development.

Payment and settlement services

Banks provide essential payment services that enable individuals and businesses to transfer funds and make payments. It includes electronic funds transfers (EFT), wire transfers, debit cards, credit cards, and online banking platforms. Banks play a crucial role in the payment infrastructure that facilitates transactions domestically and internationally.

Investment and wealth management

Many banks offer investment products and services to help clients grow their wealth and achieve financial goals. These may include mutual funds, stocks, bonds, retirement accounts, and advisory services such as financial planning and portfolio management. Banking advisors can help you create a retirement savings plan in Canada based on your goals and situation.

Currency issuance and management

In collaboration with central banks, banks participate in the issuance, distribution, and management of currency. They provide access to physical currency through ATMs and branches and manage digital currency through online banking platforms.

Risk management

Banks have risk management practices to safeguard depositors' funds and maintain financial stability. It includes assessing and managing credit risk associated with lending activities, liquidity risk related to funding obligations, and operational risk from internal processes and systems.

Regulation and oversight

Banks are subject to stringent regulatory oversight by government authorities to ensure financial stability, consumer protection, and adherence to banking laws and regulations. Regulatory bodies establish capital requirements, conduct audits, and enforce compliance to maintain the integrity of the banking system.

Profit oriented

Unlike credit unions and other cooperative financial institutions, banks are for-profit entities. They aim to generate revenue and maximize shareholder value through interest income, fees on services, and returns on investments.

Customer service and relationship management

Banks prioritize customer service to build long-term relationships with clients. They offer personalized assistance, financial advice, and tailored solutions to meet the diverse needs of individuals and businesses.

Safety and security of deposits

Banks

In Canada, deposits held in banks are typically insured up to $100,000 per depositor per insured category by the Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation. This federal Crown corporation provides deposit insurance for eligible deposits at member financial institutions, including banks. The coverage applies to savings accounts, chequing accounts, term deposits, and certain other accounts.

Banks are subject to rigorous regulation and supervision by federal and provincial regulators, such as the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) at the federal level and provincial regulators for credit unions. These regulatory bodies set capital adequacy requirements, conduct regular audits, and enforce compliance with banking laws and regulations to ensure financial stability and protect depositor interests.

Banks are typically large, diversified financial institutions with significant assets and resources. They are often well-capitalized and have access to liquidity facilities from central banks, enhancing their ability to withstand economic fluctuations and financial challenges.

Banks employ robust risk management practices to protect depositors' funds. This includes comprehensive credit risk assessments for lending activities, liquidity management strategies, and operational risk mitigation measures.

Credit unions

Credit unions in Canada are typically insured by provincial deposit insurance programs, which vary by province or territory. Each province or territory has its deposit insurance corporation that provides coverage for deposits in credit unions up to specified limits. For example, in Ontario, deposits are insured up to $250,000 per depositor per insured credit union.

A credit union is regulated by provincial or territorial regulatory authorities, which oversee their operations and financial health. Regulatory requirements for credit unions focus on capital adequacy, liquidity management, and consumer protection.

Credit unions often have a community-oriented approach and may prioritize local economic development and member service. Their size and scope may vary, with some credit unions serving specific regions or industries.

While a credit union may be smaller than a bank, many are well-managed and financially stable. They adhere to prudent financial practices and risk management guidelines to protect member deposits.

Products and services offered

In Canada, banks and credit unions offer a wide range of products and services to meet the financial needs of individuals, businesses, and communities. While there is some overlap in the offerings of banks and credit unions, there are also distinct differences based on their organizational structures, regulatory frameworks, and member-focused missions.

Banks offer:

• Deposit accounts: Savings accounts, chequing accounts, and term deposits (GICs).

• Credit products: Personal loans, mortgages, and lines of credit.

• Investment services: Mutual funds, stocks and bonds, and retirement accounts.

• Payment and transaction services: Debit cards, credit cards, and online and mobile banking.

• Wealth management: Financial planning, estate planning, and trust services.

• Business banking: Business accounts, commercial loans, and merchant services.

• Specialized services: Foreign exchange, insurance products, and corporate banking.

Credit unions offer:

• Deposit and savings accounts: Regular savings accounts, chequing accounts, and term deposits.

• Credit and loan products: Personal loans, mortgages, and lines of credit.

• Investment services: Mutual funds, registered accounts, and education savings plans.

• Payment services: Debit cards, credit cards, and online and mobile banking.

• Community and member benefits: Community support, member education, and member discounts.

• Business services: Business accounts, commercial mortgages, and business loans.

• Insurance and wealth management: Insurance products, financial planning, and estate planning.

Comparing credit unions and banks

Here are some considerations when choosing between a bank or credit union.

Organizational structure

Credit unions are cooperatives owned and operated by their members. Each member has an equal vote in electing the board of directors, regardless of their deposit amount. Operating on a not-for-profit basis, credit unions return any profits to members through lower fees, higher savings rates, and lower loan rates.

Banks are for-profit institutions owned by shareholders. Their primary goal is to maximize profits for these shareholders, with customers not having voting rights unless they own stock in the bank. Banks aim to generate profits from interest on loans, service fees, and investments, which are then distributed to shareholders in the form of dividends.

Unlike credit unions, banks serve a broader customer base without specific community ties, focusing on growth and expanding market share. Their focus is often community-oriented, serving specific communities such as geographic areas, employee groups, or members of particular organizations.

Financial services offered

Credit unions typically offer competitive interest rates on savings and checking accounts, along with lower fees. They provide lower interest rates on personal loans, auto loans, and mortgages, and often feature lower interest rates and fees on credit cards. Investment products, such as mutual funds and retirement accounts, are sometimes available through partnerships. Credit unions emphasize financial education, providing resources and workshops to help members manage their finances.

Banks offer a wide variety of account options, often with more robust online and mobile banking features. They provide extensive loan products, including specialized loans for businesses, education, and personal needs. Banks also offer a wide range of credit card options with various rewards programs, and comprehensive investment services, including mutual funds, stocks, bonds, and wealth management services. Furthermore, banks provide specialized services such as foreign exchange, insurance products, and corporate banking services.

Customer service

Credit unions emphasize a member-centric approach, often providing more personalized and friendly service. Their strong focus on supporting local communities and initiatives enhances the member experience. Due to their non-profit status, credit unions generally offer lower fees and better interest rates on deposits and loans. This personalized and community-oriented service can be particularly valuable for members who prioritize local engagement and cost-effective banking.

Banks typically have a larger exchange network of branches and ATMs, providing greater convenience for customers. They invest heavily in technology, offering sophisticated online and mobile banking platforms with extensive features. The professional services provided by banks include specialized financial advisors and wealth management services, which can cater to diverse and complex financial needs.

The high level of accessibility and technological advancement can significantly enhance the customer experience for those who value convenience and comprehensive financial solutions.

Safety and security

Deposits in credit unions are insured by provincial deposit insurance programs, with coverage limits and specifics varying by province. Credit unions are regulated by provincial or territorial regulatory authorities, ensuring their operations and financial health are closely monitored to protect members' funds.

Deposits in banks are insured by the CDIC up to $100,000 per depositor per insured category. Banks are heavily regulated by federal bodies such as the OSFI, as well as provincial regulators for specific aspects of banking operations. A robust regulatory framework contributes to the safety and stability of deposits in banks.

Value to customers

Credit unions often provide lower fees and better rates, which can translate to significant cost savings for members. Profits are reinvested into the credit union or distributed among members, enhancing member value. The strong community focus and personalized service can provide added value, especially for those who prioritize local engagement and a member-first approach.

Banks offer comprehensive banking products and services that can meet diverse needs, including those of businesses and high-net-worth individuals. Their extensive branch and ATM networks, coupled with advanced digital banking capabilities, offer great accessibility and convenience. Larger banks' significant financial resources contribute to their stability and ability to offer competitive products, making them a reliable choice for many consumers.

Let KOHO kickstart your financial journey

Embarking on your financial journey can be both exciting and challenging. However, with the right tools and guidance, you can achieve your financial goals. Establishing sound financial habits and practising responsible credit management are key steps in building a strong financial foundation. KOHO is here to support you every step of the way, offering accessible tools and expert advice to help you navigate your financial path.

Our comprehensive resources provide robust support for budgeting and tracking your expenditures, giving you valuable insights into your credit profile. KOHO's virtual credit card is perfect for daily purchases, while our overdraft protection coverage cushions you for emergency expenses. Additionally, our high-interest savings account allows you to earn interest and grow your savings efficiently.

With the virtual credit card, you earn cash back while conveniently spending from your mobile wallet and an intuitive platform for easy mobile banking. Credit score apps can help monitor your credit-building progress, and you can request a free credit score from us to ensure you're on the right track.

KOHO for businesses offers specialized tools to help manage company finances effectively. Explore our various plans designed for spending and saving, and start building your credit with KOHO today. Build your credit with KOHO, take control of your financial well-being, and achieve your financial aspirations.